Dependable Insurance for Any Situation

Affordable Insurance Options from an Experienced Agent

1st Choice Insurance Services has been proudly helping the people of Starke County with their insurance needs since 1897. Our company was established on the principles of providing superior customer service and top-quality insurance solutions to all of our customers. As an independent agent, we work with several select insurance companies that have proven to be among the very best in the industry.

Our staff is committed to getting you the best possible insurance products available today to protect you, your family and your business from any unforeseen or unfortunate events. Contact our team for any assistance that you require and get a FREE quote today!
Happy family

Personal Insurance Policies

  • Auto
  • Home
  • Renters' insurance
  • Umbrella policies
  • Watercraft
  • Motor home policies
  • Scheduled property, including inland marine options
  • Motorcycle
  • Farm

Commercial Insurance Options

  • Contractors' insurance
  • Manufacturers' insurance
  • Retail
  • Wholesale
  • Professional offices
  • Restaurants
  • Garage and repair policies
  • Delivery services coverage
  • Day care policies
  • Agribusiness 
Happy customer

Life Insurance Policies We Offer

  • Term
  • Whole
  • Universal
  • Annuities

Health Insurance Coverage Opportunities

  • Traditional
  • Short-term care
  • Medicare supplements
  • Medicare Part D
  • Medicare Advantage
Call 574-896-3482 Today or 
FREE Quote!
Our team at 1st Choice Insurance Services is dedicated and responsive to your insurance needs. We have years of helpful experience in the insurance industry.

We are also proud members of the Independent Insurance Agents of America and Trusted Choice Agency!

Need a Quote? Contact Us!

Share by: