Insurance Options Made Simple

Trusted Insurance Solutions You Can Rely On

Since 1897, 1st Choice Insurance Services has proudly served the people of Starke County with expert guidance and personalized insurance solutions. Built on a foundation of exceptional customer service, we strive to make protecting your home, family, and business simple and stress-free.

As an independent agency, we partner with carefully selected, top-rated insurance companies to ensure you have access to the best coverage options available. Our knowledgeable team is dedicated to finding the right protection for your unique needs while providing service you can truly count on.

Contact us today for assistance or a FREE quote — we’re here to help!

Personal Insurance Policies

• Auto
  
• Home
  
• Renters' insurance
  
• Umbrella policies
  
• Watercraft
  
• Motor home policies
  
• Scheduled property, including inland marine options
  
• Motorcycle
  
• Farm

Commercial Insurance Options

• Contractors' insurance
• Manufacturers' insurance
• Retail
• Wholesale
• Professional offices
• Restaurants
• Garage and repair policies
• Delivery services coverage
• Day care policies
• Agribusiness 
  

Life Insurance Policies We Offer

• Term
  
• Whole
  
• Universal
• Annuities

Health Insurance Coverage Opportunities

• Short-term care
• Medicare supplements
• Medicare Part D
• Medicare Advantage